Police Release Image of Possible Suspect in Winter Park Church Fire
Police asked the public for information in the case of a person who cut down a banner with a rainbow flag on the lawn of First Congregational Church of Winter Park and set it on fire near the church doors
Jan. 27, 2026
By Beth Kassab
The Winter Park Police Department on Tuesday released an image captured from surveillance video that shows a possible suspect in the fire set at First Congregational Church of Winter Park that targeted a banner that said “Everyone is welcome here” over a sky blue background with a rainbow flag.
The photo appeared to show a man on a sidewalk in dark clothing wearing a hat and possibly a face mask. The man is also wearing dark shoes with white soles. It wasn’t clear from the information released by the police department where the image was captured or when.
An image released by police shows a potential suspect in the church fire that burned a welcome banner.
The department did not address why it waited a week since the fire that left a pile of ash and minor damage on the eastern double doors of the church to solicit help from the public in identifying a suspect.
“All avenues of investigation are being followed to identify the suspect and determine if the crime committed had a biased-based motive,” a release from the department stated.
Florida statutes call for tougher penalties on misdemeanors and felonies if there is evidence the defendant acted out of hate or prejudice based on the “race, color, ancestry, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, national origin, homeless status or advanced age of the victim.”
A pile of ash and smoke and heat damage can be seen at the church doors after the banner was set on fire. (Photos courtesy of First Congregational Church of Winter Park)
On Sunday, Senior Minister Shawn Garvey delivered an emotional sermon with a number of notable community members in the pews to show solidarity with the church such as Anna Eskamani, who represents Winter Park in the Florida House, former Mayor Steve Leary, who recently ran for Orange County commissioner, and a number of officials from Rollins College and the Mayflower, a senior community.
Garvey read a statement from Orange County Mayor Jerry Demings that said, in part, “though they destroyed the sign, they can never destroy what’s in your heart.”
Garvey told the congregation that, a times, the church’s long history of social justice work and Christian teachings are principles that “sometimes bring the heat, literally.”
“Bring it …,” he said. “…. If the building disappears, we’ll meet somewhere else. Who cares? They won’t break us.”
Garvey said the church’s newly installed surveillance cameras captured the suspect “making a beeline” toward the welcome banner just before midnight on Jan. 20. The church is widely known for its acceptance and support of the LGBTQ community often represented by the rainbow flag on the banner.
The video shows the person cutting down the banner and bringing it to the church doors before setting it on fire.
The banner stood on the lawn of First Congregational Church of Winter Park since about Easter until it was cut down and set on fire last week.
A police report released Tuesday says an unidentified witness called police about 11:50 p.m. after smelling smoke and seeing the fire while walking to the Alfond Inn, which is just across Interlachen Avenue from the church.
The fire was quickly extinguished and city Fire Marshal Jim Santoro and Det. Daniel Fritz from the state Bureau of Fire, Arson and Explosives arrived to investigate.
Santoro told the Voice that the state bureau along with Winter Park Police would take the lead in the investigation. He said the fire appeared intentionally set, though it wasn’t immediately clear what was used to start the fire.
He said such cases are unusual in Winter Park.
“This is not very common,” Santoro said. “We probably only get something like this every couple or three years and I’ve never seen one exactly like this and I’ve been with the department 36 years.”
The police report listed potential charges of attempted arson, petty theft and damage to church property.
Police are asking anyone who has any information about the incident to contact Winter Park Det. R. Budde at 407-599-3658 or Crimeline at 800-423-TIPS(8477).
WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com
Thank you again Beth for providing us with the details of this hate crime. The photo doesn’t help much but certainly there would be a trail of photos and videos from other locations nearby and I am confident the WPPD has put those together. If the doors were burned then it is arson, not attempted arson. The city officials seem to have avoided discussing this unless I have missed their statements. But very thankful for our leaders who came out to support this wonderful church. This is much more common than people are aware, and I am grateful you are pursing it in the WPV.
My understanding from talking with the fire marshal is that the charge could be attempted arson vs arson because there wasn’t much damage aside from some paint and heat damage to the door. The fire was noticed and extinguished pretty quickly, according to all the information available, so damage was very minor.
Why doesn’t the church release their camera footage as well?