Winter Park votes to pay share of SunRail as Maitland says no
The bill for the commuter train is finally coming due and Winter Park commissioners unanimously agreed the mass transit system is worth the cost
June 26, 2024
By Beth Kassab
Local cities and counties tried to avoid this day — the day the state would finally demand they start picking up the growing tab for the $65 million SunRail commuter train that runs from Poinciana to (soon) DeLand.
But now — after exhausting deadline extensions from the state, which paid for the train for its first decade, and voters’ rejection of a county sales tax increase for transportation — the bill is coming due.
The Winter Park City Commission on Wednesday voted unanimously to pay its $350,000 per year share starting in January, though the county is seeking even more money.
“I think we’re in a good spot,” said Commissioner Craig Russell. “SunRail has been good to us. It’s money well spent.”
Winter Park has the good fortune of its SunRail station that lets riders off in Central Park, just steps from a number of businesses, restaurants, Rollins College and City Hall. As a result, the city’s station is consistently one of the busiest along the 49-mile system.
Just to the north along U.S. 17-92, neighboring Maitland’s station is one of the emptiest. And its City Council took the opposite action on Monday, voting unanimously to opt out its agreement to pay about $280,000 a year for SunRail.
“I don’t relish this discussion of having to contemplate removing ourselves,” said Council member Lindsay Hall Harrison, noting she believes in the value of a robust public transit system. “… Unfortunately, our station is the least used .. as a resident and someone who has to listen to our tax base, we’re at a crossroads.”
The vote came as city officials explained they were required to give the county 180 days notice ahead of January if they planned to opt out of the inter-local agreement in place since 2011.
The council then took two additional votes to propose a deal to the county that would allow Maitland to essentially suspend its opt-out vote and get back into SunRail if the city could come to terms with the county and find a funding source before January.
City Manager Mark Reggentin told council members that the discussions with county officials have been collegial, but the city’s share is likely to increase to $700,000.
“This is just a little too hard of a dollar amount to ask citizens for,” said Maitland Council Member Vance Guthrie.
The system has struggled in generate ridership over time. The number of riders through Winter Park fell after the system opened in 2014 before peaking in 2019 at nearly 129,000, according to SunRail statistics. The pandemic led to another drop that bottomed out at 54,257 at the Winter Park station in 2022.
From June 2023 to this month, Winter Park’s station rebounded to about 105,000 riders, second only to the main Lynx Station in downtown Orlando.
Maitland, on the other hand, tallied the fewest riders last year with just under 30,000, the statistics show.
It’s unclear how Maitland’s actions could affect the system and and the station in Winter Park, where officials hope an eventual link to the airport and theme parks could bring even more of a boon to ridership.
“The real issue is a link to the airport,” said Winter Park Commissioner Todd Weaver. “I have friends and family in Europe and they say, ‘I’ll just take train’ and I’m embarrassed to say no you can’t.”
He suggested that local officials consider revising how the Tourism Development Tax (a levy paid by hotel customers) is used to allow for expenditures on mass transit rather than “to advertise Visit Orlando,” the region’s tourism marketing agency.
WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com
It’s a wise investment. Winter Park is gifted with a station a tobacco spit away from downtown shopping and eating. Maitland didn’t think it through and failed to support what could have worked and they should reconsider. I have never heard anyone say, “Hey man, what’s up? Let’s go down to party in Maitland.” And that is the problems.
I was never a cheerleader for mass transit/Sunrail but it made no sense for the train to come through our town and not stop. And 100,000+- people a month, 1000+- a day, use it. The second busiest on/off station while only running 5 workdays a week. Impressive. Why shouldn’t the city of WP get a $ credit for essentially making Sunrail relevant? And if Maitland’s projected full share is $700,000, WP’s will likely be closer to $1 million a year.
It would great to have a WP resident on the county commission advocating for the taxpayers of WP! 😉
Math Correction. My dumb mistake. 105,000 riders PER YEAR, divided by 12 months = 8750 riders per month. 2,200 per week. 450 +- per day.
We’re still the #1 suburban station. And yes, Steve Leary on the OC commission would be a huge asset to city government and taxpayers in negotiations with OC on our payment.
Steve Leary? The same Steve Leary that screwed up the Events Center and is responsible for all the progressives running this City? No thank you. There is another electable conservative in the OC race that will be great for Winter Park. Steve is a nice guy but if you think he will do anything to stop the spigot of money that goes to the convention center interests and waste more of our money, you are sadly mistaken.
Sunrail is a complete failure of a project, where selling a ticket costs more than is made. The entire project should be shut down as a sunk cost, and not floated at tax payer expense. The entire enterprise only makes sense if one considers it a money laundering operation. Laughable that WP tax payers have to pay to keep it afloat. And don’t make the argument that 450 people come a day is worth it. We have no idea how many of those people would come anyway and how many actually spend money in WP.
https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2017/02/24/sunrail-ticket-revenue-is-less-than-ticketing-expense/
I believe that if the powers to be can FINALLY get the airport connection together which was promised 10 years ,locals would use it,,,let us support Steve for county commission,maybe than winter park has a face again in government
SunRail is amazing for WP. We can all stop fighting about “affordable housing” now because the station we pay for provides a convenient and affordable gateway to the city. Therefore, living affordably within city limits isn’t even necessary. Right?
The best thing about SunRail is that it’s redirected freight train traffic out of town.
The worst aspect of “commuter rail” is the transit oriented development it excuses by virtue of its existence. Lots of money to developers of high density housing along any rail corridor at a huge cost to quality of life. Traffic, density, traffic, density, traffic. This isn’t big city mass transit. It’s central Florida commuter rail.