Save Christmas? Petition is misleading

Save Christmas? Petition is misleading

Save Christmas? Petition is misleading

City officials asked the Park Avenue District to brand the season of events as “holiday,” but Christmas is not disappearing from the names of the individual events

Sept. 9, 2025

By Beth Kassab

Hold your reindeer, Winter Park. Before you get fired up about the Change.Org petition to “Save Christmas in Winter Park,” let’s take a look at the facts.

The petition, which had 570 signatures by Tuesday afternoon in the city of 30,000 people, makes several allegations, asserting that 70 years of Christmas event traditions are “at risk.”

“In recent planning, the city has agreed to fund holiday lighting only if the word “Christmas” is removed,” the petition states. “As a result, Central Park’s Christmas Tree is now called a ‘Holiday Tree,’ and the annual tree lighting event has been rebranded as ‘Winter on the Avenue,’ intentionally avoiding any mention of Christmas.”

But those statements are misleading and, in some parts, false.

The city is, in fact, asking for the overall name of the events season to change. But no changes are being requested for the titles of the half dozen main events that make up the season — and most of those use the word “Christmas.”

New lights in Central Park made up part of the city’s display in 2024.

Gigi Papa, a Winter Park resident who frequently attends and speaks at City Commission meetings, is listed on the change.org page as the “petition starter.” Papa did not immediately respond to an email and text message seeking comment about the petition’s statements.

Here’s what happened and why the city requested the change:

In 2024, the Park Avenue District, a relatively new group of merchants, businesses and residents who aim to support the central retail hub, took over coordination of the city’s annual light display and decor.

With about $100,000 from the city government and matching dollars from private donors, the group added more lights, an Instagram-worthy walk-through light cathedral in Central Park, a children’s carousel in front of City Hall and new wreaths and other festive touches.

For years, the city used the name “Hometown Holidays,” to advertise its season of events that run from mid-November, when the display goes up, through New Year’s.

The Park Avenue District changed the name to “Christmas on Park” last year.

City spokeswoman Clarissa Howard said Mayor Sheila DeCiccio heard some complaints about the entire season of events being branded as “Christmas” after it had been branded as “Hometown Holidays” for so long. So the city, which is providing about $60,000 for the decor this year, requested the name be changed to “Holidays on Park.”

“We are not breaking tradition,” Howard said. “It’s a season, it’s not one event. We called the season Hometown Holidays because there are holidays other than Christmas happening downtown.”

In 2021, the city added to Central Park a menorah for Hanukkah and a kinara for Kwanzaa.

A menorah is part of the annual lights display in Central Park.

Carina Sexton, executive director of the Park Avenue District, said she expects the name will change based on the city’s request.

“Regardless of the name, we feel confident that the magic of the season will remain the same and we are thrilled to welcome our community and visitors alike back to the Park Avenue District to celebrate with us,” she said.

Individual long-standing city events with the name Christmas aren’t changing and no one from the city has asked for them to be changed, Howard said. Sexton confirmed she has not received any other requests for changes.

Those events include:

“Christmas in the Park” on Dec. 4 is the annual evening that features a display of lighted Tiffany glass windows from the Morse Museum and Christmas music from the Bach Festival Society and a brass ensemble.

“The Christmas Parade” will be on Dec. 6, which is sponsored by the Winter Park Chamber of Commerce.

And “Tuba Christmas,” another musical event, will take place on Dec. 20 this year.

The name “Winter on the Avenue,” another event lead by the chamber, has been used for years and is not part of a rebrand as the petition alleges.

That will take place on Dec. 5 this year and is described on the Chamber website: “Begin the evening at the Annual Holiday Tree Lighting in Central Park just east of the Winter Park train station. Winners of the Holiday Art Competition will be recognized, Rabbi Dovid Dubov of Chabad Orlando will do a menorah lighting ceremony ushering in the season of Chanukah, and Winter Park Mayor Sheila DeCiccio will lead us in a countdown as we light the Christmas Tree.”

The petition demands the city “return to using the name Christmas Tree instead of Holiday Tree,” even though the chamber’s description explicitly refers to the mayor leading the lighting of the “Christmas Tree.”

“The city does not call it a ‘holiday tree,'” Howard said.

In holiday press releases dating back to 2005, the ceremony has always been referred to simply as the “annual tree-lighting” without the word Christmas. Though Christmas was, and still is, included in many of the event names throughout the seasonal lineup.

“We can’t return to doing something that we haven’t done,” Howard said. “There is no tradition at risk. All of our events are still happening.”

In a press release in August about the light display that will go up Nov. 13, the city noted the season of events and decor brought in about 350,000 people last year, about 7% higher than the previous year.

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

Correction: An earlier version of this story stated the wrong year the city added a menorah and kinara to Central Park, due to incorrect information provided to the Voice. The year was 2021.

 

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Winter Park D-Day veteran, 103, to get Gold Medal for Army Ranger service

Winter Park D-Day veteran, 103, to get Gold Medal for Army Ranger service

Winter Park D-Day veteran, 103, to get Gold Medal for Army Ranger service

John Raaen, a resident of the Mayflower, joins a list of recipients of a Congressional medal first given to George Washington

Sept. 2, 2025

By Stephen Hudak

This story is part of the News Collaborative of Central Florida, a group of 10 local news outlets working towards a more informed and engaged region. It was originally published by the Orlando Sentinel.

Medals didn’t matter on D-Day to soldiers like John Carpenter Raaen, Jr.

“Never occurred to me,” said Raaen, now 103, a Winter Park resident and the only surviving Army Ranger who stormed Omaha Beach in France on June, 6, 1944, in a pivotal battle often regarded as the beginning of the end of World War II. “As a matter of fact, medals didn’t mean a lot to any of us.”

He and thousands of Allied troops who faced fortified German artillery fire hoped just to survive the firefight.

“We didn’t think many of us would be alive June 7,” he said.

About 4,400 Allied troops died in the battle, including 2,500 Americans.

Raaen, whose name is pronounce “ron,” moved to Central Florida after retiring in 1979 at the rank of major general. Among the many recognitions he earned during his 36 years of service was a Silver Star for valor in combat on D-Day when he was 22.

Now he is about to receive another prestigious honor: a Congressional Gold Medal.

The award, the nation’s highest civilian honor, is intended to serve as a lasting symbol of the nation’s gratitude, recognizing the U.S. Army Rangers of World War II for their unwavering, extraordinary bravery and critical contributions in key battles in  the war.

Raaen’s vivid D-Day memories, recalling the perils his Rangers faced, are memorialized in interviews posted on Youtube by the World War II Veterans History Project and the American Veterans Center. He has said the grim opening of the World War II drama “Saving Private Ryan,” which recreates the Allies’  bloody landing on Omaha Beach, “offers a little hint of what it was like.”

“It was just plain out and out hell,” he said.

Oil, steel, rubber and human flesh were all ablaze.

Dead and dying soldiers were scattered on the beach like seashells.

“The machine gun firing, the rifle firing went over our heads like a bunch of bees,” he said in the History Project interview. “I’m talking thousands and thousands of small arms rounds every minute, passing over your head and occasionally hitting somebody next to you.”

His military career seemed inevitable. The son of an Army officer, Raaen was born at Fort Benning, Georgia.

He was raised on army posts and graduated from the Military Academy at West Point in January 1943.

Nicknamed “Red,” for his once red hair, Raaen authored his own first-hand account of the D-Day invasion, “INTACT,” which relied on his personal letters, official war documents and sharp memory to tell the story of the 5th Ranger Infantry Battalion as they helped establish a foothold for Allied troops and supplies to roll onto Berlin.

He provided oral histories for the BBC documentary series “D-Day: The Last Heroes” and for the Smithsonian Channel. He has been interviewed by more than two dozen war historians, who cite him in books and papers. Among those historians are presidential biographer Stephen E. Ambrose, author of the World War II best-seller “Band of Brothers.”

Raaen was involved in the development of anti-tank projectiles, armor-piercing small arms ammunition, artillery nuclear warheads and arming devices, according to his biography in the U.S. Army Ordnance Hall of Fame to which he was inducted in 2009.

A friend, retired U.S. Army Lt. Colonel Buck Leahy, listened with rapt attention last week when Raaen was interviewed again.

“I think over the course of my life, I’ve been fortunate enough to know a very small number of men who are genuine heroes,” Leahy said. “To a man, they are humble, unassuming, modest people, and John is…absolutely emblematic of that.”

Raaen could not attend the Congressional Gold Medal ceremony in Washington in June where he and the other four surviving Army Rangers from 6,500 who served in World War II were feted.

He will formally receive his medal this month at a ceremony at The Mayflower in Winter Park, the retirement community where he lives.

David Lyle Williams, president of the Descendants of World War II Rangers, read a note at the Washington ceremony from Raaen accepting the medal on behalf of all Rangers including the many who died in service to their country. Most who volunteered for the dangerous duty as a Ranger often said they wanted action and they got it, he said.

The regiment’s motto, minted on the gold medal, is “Rangers Lead the Way!”

“Many volunteered. Few were chosen,” Willliams said. “One man was rejected because he had false teeth.”

Williams said the soldier appealed, telling the colonel, “I don’t want to eat the Germans. I want to kill them.”

The appeal was persuasive. He became a Ranger.

The Congressional Gold Medal is a recognition of distinguished achievement and service.

The first recipient was George Washington in 1776, honored for his “wise and spirited conduct” in the American Revolution.

Originally conceived to honor the new nation’s military heroes, the award was created by Congress then expanded to recognize a diverse group of honorees and achievements in arts, music or sports; pioneering work in aeronautics and space, medicine and science.

The medal has been awarded to Civil Rights icons like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Rosa Parks.

Some are obscure like Michigan boat-builder John Horn, Jr. , honored in 1874 for reportedly rescuing more than 100 people from drowning over an 11-year span, many of whom had fallen into the Detroit River getting on or off ferryboats. Others are world renowned — golfer/philanthropist Arnold Palmer,  singer Frank Sinatra and Catholic saint Mother Teresa.

Others recognized with the Congressional Gold Medal include:

  • Aviation pioneers Wilbur and Orville Wright, recognized in 1909 for demonstrating to the world the potential of aerial navigation.
  • Scientist/inventor Thomas A. Edison, recognized in 1928 for development of “inventions that have revolutionized civilization.”
  • Dr. Jonas E. Salk, honored in 1955 “for discovering a serum for the prevention of polio.”
  • Filmmaker and businessman Walt Disney, recognized in 1968 for “outstanding contributions to the United States and the world.”
  • Baseball player Roberto Clemente, honored in 1973 for “outstanding athletic, civil, charitable, and humanitarian contributions.” He perished in a plane crash in 1972 on a humanitarian mission to deliver aid to the earthquake-ravaged nation of Nicaragua.
  • Religious leaders Ruth and Billy Graham, honored in 1996 for “outstanding and enduring contributions toward faith, morality, and charity.”
  • The U.S. Capitol Police, recognized in August 2021, for protecting the U.S. on January 6, 2021 against a mob of insurrectionists.

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Today Show footage, which snubbed Winter Park, used to defend Visit Orlando

Today Show footage, which snubbed Winter Park, used to defend Visit Orlando

Today Show footage, which snubbed Winter Park, used to defend Visit Orlando

The agency is under fire after a county audit of its spending as Winter Park also took exception to the way it used the city without promoting it

Aug. 27, 2025

By Gabrielle Russon

Visit Orlando promoted the Today Show coverage filmed in Winter Park to defend itself from a critical county audit, but the tourism association didn’t mention city officials’ complaints with the TV segment.

Visit Orlando leaders appeared before the Orange County Board of Commissioners Tuesday following Comptroller Phil Diamond’s audit last month that raised concerns about Visit Orlando’s spending. 

Ultimately, the county board took no action Tuesday and will revisit the issues in December as county staff work with Visit Orlando to address the audit’s results and go over the contract.

Assistant Comptroller Wendy Kittleson said Visit Orlando may have misspent an estimated $20 million dating back to 2019.

Visit Orlando CEO Casandra Matej said her organization openly shared its records with the auditors and is already working with the county to address many of the audit’s findings. She defended her organization, saying it helps promote tourism that fuels a major economic impact to the region.

The county board spent three hours discussing Visit Orlando’s value and the audit’s findings.

The debate comes as some officials are pushing to free up the 6% Orange County hotel tax to be spent on public transit, housing and other community needs instead of going toward advertisements and marketing for tourism. Meanwhile, the tourism industry is fighting to keep the status quo. 

Winter Park officials, for example, brought up during last year’s budget discussions whether the tourism development tax could be used to help pay for SunRail, which operates one of its most popular stops in the city.

This week amid the marathon debate during the county meeting, Visit Orlando played footage from when Today Show set up in Winter Park — just steps away from the train station — to cover Epic Universe’s grand opening in May.

The video showed off the Today Show’s set, celebrity weatherman Al Roker and the crowd holding signs. 

“It’s not just the theme park aspect,” said Broadway star Michael James, a Central Florida native, who was tapped as guest in the segment. “We got culture here, y’all! We got culture in Orlando.”

For Visit Orlando, the Today Show was a big deal to tell Orlando’s story.

“This is so important because we’re able to reach a national audience from ecotourism to dining to our amazing sports in Orlando. We definitely have it all and this is an amazing opportunity,” Matej said in a clip played at Tuesday’s county meeting.

A local eye would recognize the scene as Central Park, the beloved green space in Winter Park’s popular retail and dining corridor along Park Avenue. But in front of more than 30 million Today Show viewers, no one actually mentioned that Winter Park was the backdrop.

“They didn’t say at all they were in Winter Park?” asked Commissioner Craig Russell afterward during a city meeting in late May.

“Not one word,” Mayor Sheila DeCiccio said.

The mayor said she supported no longer giving freebies to Visit Orlando “unless credit is given to Winter Park or they can pay fees like anyone else renting the park.”

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

New Park Avenue archway underscores historic Winter Park

New Park Avenue archway underscores historic Winter Park

New Park Avenue archway underscores historic Winter Park

A group of private donors combined with public dollars made the $400,000 project possible

Aug. 25, 2025

By Beth Kassab

Winter Park leaders on Monday celebrated the installation of the first of two archways that will bookend Park Avenue.

The $400,000 pair of signs emphasize the city’s commitment to historic preservation and were one of the last projects spearheaded by former Planning & Zoning Director Jeff Briggs before he retired at the start of the year.

Mayor Sheila DeCiccio gives remarks at an event to celebrate the new signs on Monday.

The City Commission provided about half the money for the arches made by Don Bell Signs and eight private donors covered the remainder.

Briggs has said the calls for donations were among the “easiest” he ever made with lots of enthusiasm for the markers that call even more attention to Winter Park’s popular dining and retail corridor, which was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2011.

The sign on the north end stands at the intersection of Park and Webster avenues next to the public golf course known as the Winter Park Nine and in sight of historic home-turned-venue Casa Feliz.

The city seal now adorns City Hall as part of a refresh of the building over the summer.

A second arch on the south end near Park and Aloma avenues and just across the street from Rollins College is slated to go up at the end of September.

Private donors to the cause are: Rick Baldwin; Jim and Diana Barnes; Mike and Gail Winn; the Allan E. and Linda S. Keen Family; Larry and Joy Williams Private Foundation; Edyth Bush Charitable Foundation; Joe and Sarah Galloway Foundation and the Elizabeth Morse Genius Foundation.

The signs aren’t the only noticeable public upgrade along Park Avenue. City Hall, at the intersection of Lyman Avenue is sporting a new paint job with the city seal, featuring a peacock, now prominently displayed to passersby.

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

 

 

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Parade of Bands canceled for second year

Parade of Bands canceled for second year

Parade of Bands canceled for second year

The future of the Pop-Tart Bowl tradition that brought crowds to Winter Park is still uncertain

Aug. 12, 2025

By Gabrielle Russon

Paul Canchester, a retiree from the Chicago suburbs, has brought his family to Winter Park to watch the Parade of Bands for years as part of their annual Orlando vacation. The memories started when his kids, now adults, were young.

He described the anticipation waiting for the two university bands in town for the Pop-Tart Bowl shutting down the entire Winter Park downtown to play for free to the big crowd.

“Goodness, it was such excitement,” Canchester said. “We got a seat along Park Avenue and you could hear them playing before you could see them. You knew they were coming because you could hear the music a block or two away. And then it gradually got louder and louder, and then they came around the corner, and there they were, lined up with their uniforms on and playing their music. It was fantastic.”

Canchester said he is disappointed and fears it might not return after the city confirmed to Winter Park Voice that the parade is canceled for the second year in a row. 

“The residents love it. The tourists love it,” Canchester said. “I hope they can find a time for the bands to play.”

Similar to last year, the parade is a casualty because of the game’s timing in the evolving college football playoffs.

One city official expressed hope the parade might return in 2026 or 2027 and said the Winter Park will always be a happy Parade of Bands host — whenever that may be.

The game’s weekend afternoon start time – 3:30 p.m., Dec. 27 – makes it logistically impossible to transport the bands to Winter Park for the parade, feed them lunch and then send them off for their other responsibilities for the bowl game, Miller said. 

“It just makes it a really tight schedule,” said Johnny Miller, Winter Park’s special events manager, adding the kickoff time is decided by the TV networks. “It’s not in our control or the Pop-Tart Bowl’s control. … Sometimes the lower tier bowls, they get what they get.”

Already, Miller’s phone is ringing as people wonder about the parade’s status even though it’s too early to know which teams are playing in the game.

Somebody even called Winter Park last year, inquiring if another city could poach the parade.

“I don’t want them to think Winter Park doesn’t want to do it,” Miller said.

The Parade of Bands became an annual tradition dating back to 2007 and easily drew at least 2,000 or more — especially if a Florida team was playing in Camping World Stadium.

College football underwent a major change when it expanded to a 12-team playoff bracket in the 2024-25 season. There is talk of more bowl games getting added to the playoffs which could potentially shake up the Pop-Tart Bowl so it ends up in a more high-profile, later time slot to bring back the parade, Miller said.

Miller said it’s unclear the timeline for the proposed playoff expansion.

“It could happen next year. It may be two more years,” Miller said. “Nobody knows.”

But he added the city will welcome back the Parade of Bands as soon as it can.

“It’ll always have a home here,” Miller said.

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

Gabrielle Russon is a freelance reporter and former reporter for the Orlando Sentinel, where she covered K-12 education, colleges and universities and the tourism industry. She lives in Orlando with her family and writes about politics, education, theme parks and the courts.

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Winter Park gives main character energy in ‘Happy Wife’

Winter Park gives main character energy in ‘Happy Wife’

Winter Park gives main character energy in 'Happy Wife'

The authors explain how the city and a number of local haunts became a lavish — and sometimes dark — setting for the novel featured by Jenna Bush on the Today Show

Aug. 12, 2025

By Beth Kassab

Kendall Shores writes about Winter Park like a local because she is one.

Her parents met at Rollins College and married in Knowles Memorial Chapel. She attended Park Maitland, Trinity Preparatory and Winter Park High, where she rowed crew.

She’s seen the glitter of Park Avenue and the dirt swept under the rugs in the old-guard historic homes and the ultra modern mansions that surround the central district.

So when Shores talked to co-author Meredith Lavender about a setting for their debut novel “Happy Wife” she felt called to draw on her personal experience.

“I said, ‘Look, I know everyone thinks their hometown is interesting, but hear me out,'” Shores recalled. “… I think we understand that readers really enjoy a strong sense of place. And Winter Park,  when you are there, has a strong sense of place.”

Cue the applause from the urban planners and preservationists.

‘Happy Wife’ throttled to the buzzsphere after the Today Show’s Jenna Bush featured it last month and called it a “delicious, fun summer” read.

City Commissioner Warren Lindsey then passed out copies at the next City Hall meeting and declared the mention not only a worthwhile book rec, but also a little atonement for the Today Show’s recent snub of Winter Park.Not a word about the city was spoken during multiple unrelated segments filmed at Central Park for the Today Show’s third hour, which only promoted neighboring Orlando. The May appearances, coordinated by Visit Orlando, prompted Mayor Sheila DeCiccio to question the city’s future cooperation and waiver of park rental fees with the taxpayer-funded tourism marketing agency.

“They made up for it,” Lindsey said. “And we have to be able to make fun of ourselves a little bit.”

Is it any wonder the city lends itself so well to fiction?

The book is filled with local references from Interlachen Country Club to Fiddler’s Green Irish Pub and the condominium Enron’s Kenneth Lay called home when he was still with Florida Gas Co.

“Do you not like living here?” the main character, Nora, a 28-year-old whose marriage is at the center of the thriller, asks a friend.

“I like tax breaks. I like boat rides and sunsets on the lake and summer all year. But people like Autumn act like this place is $%&ing Paris or something. It’s Florida, not the %&* center of the universe.”

“You’re spicy this morning. Who hurt you? Did someone at the party try to tell you the Morse Museum is better than the MoMA again?”

Lavender and Shores, who both live in Atlanta, say they’ve heard talk of people wondering if any of the characters are based on specific individuals, but they aren’t.

All of the characters formed organically as the authors said they explored the dangers of “romanticizing your life, your partner or even your community too much” through a mystery with a number of turns.

Lavender, a television writer whose credits include “Nashville,” grew up on the north shore of Chicago and hadn’t spent much time in Central Florida.

Now, though, she’s had a proper introduction to Winter Park via Shores including, of course, the Scenic Boat Tour.

“People really have Florida in their minds as one thing and, for me, it had touches of Wisconsin and lake country and I loved that,” she said.

The co-authors expect to be in town again soon for events related to the book. Stay tuned for dates.

And there’s already another story in the works that builds on the last.

Winter Park, Shores said, continues to be the “anchor.”

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

To comment or read comments from others, click here →