Synagogue Proposal Faces Fresh Scrutiny as Winter Park Commissioner Defends Impartiality

Synagogue Proposal Faces Fresh Scrutiny as Winter Park Commissioner Defends Impartiality

Synagogue Proposal Faces Fresh Scrutiny as Winter Park Commissioner Defends Impartiality

Chabad of Greater Orlando is seeking to build the city’s first permanent synagogue near Park Avenue that would also include a daycare and rooftop deck

Oct. 23, 2026

By Beth Kassab

A second vote required to approve what would be Winter Park’s first permanent synagogue has been delayed again, as opponents challenge the project’s compliance with city code and raise questions about a city commissioner’s acceptance of complimentary Orlando Magic tickets from a friend who received them from the rabbi leading the project.

The City Commission was scheduled to take up the matter Oct. 28, but Chabad of Greater Orlando, the organization behind the proposed synagogue and daycare, and GAI Consultants, which is seeking to build five townhomes on the parcel, asked to postpone the hearing until Dec. 9.

Frank Santos, who says he has spent $15,000 on consultants to review the project, is aggressively contesting the proposal. He argues that it would negatively affect a townhome he owns and other nearby properties through significantly increased traffic and noise, as well as the introduction of a predominantly nonresidential use on the site of the El Cortez Apartments at the corner of Morse Boulevard and Knowles Avenue.

Santos’ attorney, former Orange County Commissioner Ted Edwards, and consultant Jeff Briggs, who retired less than two years ago as the city’s longtime planning director, have identified what they describe as “significant missed setbacks, buffers, parking deficiencies and related matters.” They also contend that the synagogue approval process must essentially start over, with the proposal returning to the Planning & Zoning Board, according to a letter Edwards sent to the City Commission earlier this week.

A rendering provided to the city shows what the synagogue could look like.

City officials did not respond to a request for comment on the letter. Rebecca Wilson, the attorney representing Chabad and GAI, has said at public meetings that the project has worked to make alterations to be compatible with the neighborhood and agreed to more than 20 conditions including no amplified noise on the roof deck and limiting the number of children in the daycare.

She has said there are more than residential uses next to the property, including a church and office and retail space.

“Your code itself says that religious institutions and daycares are allowed if we go through this conditional use process,” Wilson said on Sept. 9, noting she’s lost count of the number of conditions placed on the development but it has “proven it’s compatibility” with the neighborhood.

Santos said the townhome he purchased in 2019 on Interlachen Avenue, which backs up to the proposed synagogue property, represents a “significant investment.” He said he does not live there and does not intend to do so in the future. Instead, he lives in another Winter Park home, a little more than a mile away, north of Palm Cemetery.

“My bigger concern is the impact on downtown Winter Park and the greater area,” he said Friday.

Santos, chief executive officer of Rosen Hotels & Resorts, also said he is communicating with Jonathan Beaton, owner of the public relations firm Inside Advantage PR. Beaton reached out to Santos and offered to help his cause, citing his own concerns about traffic and parking as a Winter Park resident.

Beaton filed a public records request with the city on Sept. 12, three days after the City Commission voted 4-1 to table the second vote, with Commissioner Kris Cruzada dissenting. Commissioner Elizabeth Ingram, who had voted in favor of the project as part of a 3-2 vote in August, said she could not support it again that night because of unanswered questions about the daycare’s playground and concerns about traffic.

A map included in city documents shows the location of the property in question.

Beaton, who previously served as a spokesman for former Congressman Alan Grayson, requested a wide range of records concerning communications to and from commissioners and city staff related to the project.

The request yielded hundreds of emails involving all five commissioners, but only Ingram’s records appeared to include text messages and calendar entries.

Among those records was a text message Ingram sent to Rabbi Dovid Dubov, one of Chabad’s leaders, at 9:31 a.m. on June 4:

“Good morning, Rabbi Dubov! we had a great time at the magic game – thanks again!!! I would be happy to meet with you to discuss the synagogue.”

She also suggested a potential meeting date.

Dubov replied, “Great to hear!” and the two settled on a meeting in July.

Beaton sent the Voice a screenshot showing only that exchange last week and also contacted other media outlets.

The Voice’s review of additional records and interviews provided further context about the tickets and the timing of the communications.

Other records and interviews revealed that the Orlando Magic game in question took place in April, before Ingram said she had seen or was even aware of Chabad’s plans, which would later come before the commission. She received the tickets through a friend who had gotten them from Dubov. The tickets were among dozens of complimentary tickets Chabad distributed to promote the game, which coincided with the annual Jewish Heritage Night with the Orlando Magic.

And Ingram’s message to the rabbi on the screenshot was actually a response to a message she received from him two days earlier on June 2, the same day Chabad and GAI held a community meeting with neighborhood residents. The meeting took place about a month before the proposal was first tabled at the July 7 Planning & Zoning Board meeting.

Dubov’s June 2 message read:

“Good afternoon Commissioner Elizabeth Ingram! I hope you’re doing well and that you enjoyed our Jewish Heritage Night with the Orlando Magic back on April 6. I received your contact information [from a mutual friend] and wanted to reach out regarding the development of our first synagogue in Winter Park. As we move through the planning process, I would love the opportunity to share the vision and current plans with you, hear your thoughts, and receive your feedback as well. If you are open to meeting sometime, please let me know what works best for you. It would be greatly appreciated.”

Dubov told the Voice in a text message that Chabad has participated in the annual event with the Magic for years and has distributed “hundreds of complimentary tickets as part of our efforts to make Jewish Heritage Night welcoming and accessible to all.” He declined to answer additional questions.

Ingram, who took office in March after running unopposed, said Dubov gave the tickets to a friend of hers, and she attended the April 6 game with her family.

She said she did not hear from the rabbi again until two months later, when he contacted her after obtaining her phone number from another mutual connection, as he explained in his message.

Ingram said she nearly always agrees to meet with people who request a conversation and has also met with opponents of the synagogue proposal. Records show that she had a meeting scheduled with Santos around the same time, on July 14.

Ingram said she thanked Dubov for the tickets out of politeness because he brought them up when he initiated their text exchange.

“He never brought it up again,” she said. “Do you really think I’m going to be swayed on this huge development proposal from one Magic game months ago?”

Ingram said she learned from a reporter last week that opponents of the synagogue were raising questions about the Magic tickets. She then received a call from Santos, who suggested she might feel pressure to recuse herself from the next vote because she had accepted the tickets. He also told her there were photos of her in a suite at the Kia Center, where the Magic play.

Ingram said the tickets she received for Jewish Heritage Night were not for a suite. She said she later sat in a suite with friends and family at a different game that month, paying her own way. She said the photos Santos referenced, which were posted on her Facebook page, were taken at that game.

“He called me and said he has a lot of stuff,” she told the Voice. “I told him the whole story, and I thought, how can you say I’ve not been asking hard questions? Anyone could tell I was really conflicted over the plans [for the synagogue].”

In fact, it was Ingram’s questions on Sept. 9, before the Magic game became an issue, that helped prevent the proposal from winning approval that night and led to the vote being tabled. The other commissioners appeared divided, with two leaning in favor (Cruzada and Craig Russell) and two opposed (Sheila DeCiccio and Warren Lindsey). Those were the same positions they had taken during the first vote in August, leaving Ingram as the potential swing vote who could decide the matter.

Santos told the Voice that he made a “courtesy call” to Ingram about the tickets and photos he had been told were on Facebook.

“I told her I was getting photos of her and her family in a suite,” he said. “I’m not on Facebook. Other people are insinuating and trying to connect the dots, not me.”

Ingram released a statement Thursday evening saying she had asked the city attorney whether she could recuse herself from the next vote “because of the misleading narratives that have circulated regarding my attendance at the basketball game.”

“In no way am I concerned of my ability to remain fair and impartial,” she said in the statement. “I felt stepping aside would help prevent further controversy and avoid undermining public confidence in the commission’s final decision.”

But City Attorney Kurt Ardaman told her that elected officials are “required” to vote on matters before the commission because abstention is allowed only in cases involving a conflict of interest. Such conflicts require “a special private economic gain or loss” for the elected official, an immediate family member or the official’s employer. Ardaman said Ingram does not have a conflict of interest in this matter.

“I listen to our residents and consider different perspectives, but my decisions are my own,” Ingram said in the statement. “I believe every development application deserves fair consideration under the applicable laws and land-use standards. Political support, personal relationships and outside criticism does not determine my vote.”

Ingram also said she did not believe the tickets were worth more than $100. However, she has now filed a gift disclosure form required under state ethics rules “in the interest of full disclosure.”

Additional records provided by the city show no text messages between Ingram and Dubov after June 23 when they continued a discussion about scaling back the synagogue’s size in response to community feedback.

On June 19, Ingram had shared her concerns about the scale of the proposal with Dubov.

An earlier rendering of the synagogue shows a different style of architecture before community feedback.

“I wanted to let you know this now in case you are willing and able to work with the architect on a revised concept that would be slightly smaller,” she wrote. “I think that is going to be the biggest hurdle going into the planning and zoning meeting and then commission meeting.”

It is not unusual for commissioners to share feedback on development plans or request architectural changes.

The Planning & Zoning Board approved the project with scaled-back renderings on Aug. 4 in a 5-0 vote. One member was absent, and another abstained because he works as an urban planner and had been asked to consult on the project before the application was submitted.

Ingram also received text messages and emails from other people about the proposal, including a text from Nikki Seybold, who is working with Santos and Edwards to determine whether the synagogue project complies with city requirements for parking and setbacks. Seybold texted Ingram on the morning of Aug. 28, two days after the commission’s first vote on the project, and asked whether they could speak by phone.

“Hey Nikki! Yes, I am actually just walking out of a doctor’s appointment so I will give you a call in a few minutes when I get in my car,” Ingram responded.

Ingram said her text exchanges with Seybold and Dubov reflect her philosophy of meeting with as many people as possible to learn about city issues.

“I’m very friendly to everyone,” she said. “They might bring up something to me that I hadn’t considered.”

Santos said he has a meeting scheduled next week with Edwards, the city attorney and city staff to determine whether the proposal violates city code, as he contends.

“I don’t want to spend any more of my time or my money on this issue,” he said. “I want it to go away.”

But he said that if the city did not require all the necessary waivers to bring the project into compliance with code, that would raise questions about other developments, particularly as construction has ramped up in downtown Winter Park in recent years.

“Did the Alfond Inn apply for all the waivers? Did the Rollins museum apply for all the waivers?” he asked. “This is not just about this project; it’s about past projects and future projects.”

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com 

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

What Do Florida’s Three Proposed Constitutional Amendments Mean?

What Do Florida’s Three Proposed Constitutional Amendments Mean?

What Do Florida's Three Proposed Constitutional Amendments Mean?

By now, many people are familiar with Amendment 3, which would reduce homestead property taxes. But what about Amendments 1 and 2? An explainer:

Oct. 20, 2026

By Abe Aboraya

This story originally appeared in Oviedo Community News and is published here as part of a sharing agreement among members of the News Collaborative of Central Florida. 

Voters getting a ballot for the November election will have three constitutional amendments to vote on. So what are they, and what would they do?

The general election is Nov. 3 and early voting is already underway and runs until Nov. 1.

Constitutional amendments in Florida must get 60% of the vote to pass. All three amendments this year were put on the ballot by Florida lawmakers.

Aubrey Jewett, associate professor and associate school director at the University of Central Florida’s School of Politics, Security and International Affairs, said voters will need to do their research on the amendments.

“We are voting whether or not to put things into the Constitution,” Jewett said. “And what we put in there really does matter.”

What is Amendment 1?

Amendment 1 would require the Florida Legislature to increase budget reserves from the current 10% to a 25% reserve.

It would require the Legislature to put $750 million into reserves annually until the threshold is reached, except in years when there’s a budget shortfall or an emergency, like a hurricane. Advocates for the bill said it’s a hedge against a downturn in the economy, while critics say it’s unnecessary, and that surpluses should go back to residents in the form of tax breaks.

The Republican Party of Florida has endorsed Amendment 1.

“This amendment will help strengthen Florida’s rainy day fund so the state can handle storms, downturns, and other emergencies without raising taxes or raiding the budget,” the state’s GOP wrote on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter.

Other groups have come out against the amendment, saying the money could be better spent elsewhere. That includes some union representatives, and Gov. Ron DeSantis.

DeSantis recommended a no vote, calling it a “foolish” constitutional amendment.

“We already have a maxed out rainy day fund and have run the largest surpluses in state history,” DeSantis wrote on X. “Any additional revenue should be used for lower taxes, including assisting local governments with grants so that homestead properties can be exempt from local property tax.  Surplus revenue could also be used to remove tolls once the property tax issue is settled.”

How the text will appear on your ballot: 

Proposing an amendment to the State Constitution to increase the amount of funds that may be retained in the budget stabilization fund from 10% to 25% of general revenue collections, require the legislature to transfer the lesser of $750 million or the amount required to reach 25% of the general revenue collections each year unless certain conditions are met, and allow the legislature to withdraw funds for critical state needs.

Check here for the full text of the amendment. Check here for an analysis of the bill

What is Amendment 2?

Amendment 2 deals with property taxes, but specifically for farms and agritourism businesses.

In Florida, businesses pay property taxes on the value of the land and buildings. But they also pay a property tax on the value of all the business equipment. It’s called Tangible Personal Property, and can include the value of furniture, tools, appliances and other equipment.

That includes farm equipment, like tractors. Amendment 2 would eliminate the property taxes for that farm equipment across the state.

“The Tangible Personal Property tax literally handicaps a struggling sector of our society that we so desperately rely on,” wrote Republican Rep. Danny Alvarez when he filed the bill. “Getting rid of it allows farmers and ranchers the chance to reinvest their money in themselves in order to ensure we all have a better tomorrow.”

The state’s economists estimate that statewide it would cut $31 million from local governments if approved.

An analysis by Seeking Rents, an independent podcast and newsletter about Florida politics, estimated that at least 10 percent of the estimated tax savings under Amendment 2 would got to cannabis companies like Curaleaf, Trulieve and MÜV.

Some of the most valuable tangible personal property used in Florida agriculture belongs to companies that grow, process and sell marijuana, which is legal in this state for medicinal use, the organization reported.

How the text will appear on your ballot: 

Proposing an amendment to the State Constitution to exempt tangible personal property habitually located or typically present on land classified as agricultural, used in the production of agricultural products or for agritourism activities, and owned by the landowner or leaseholder of the agricultural land from ad valorem taxation. If approved this amendment would first apply for tax years beginning January 1, 2027.

Check here for the full text of the amendment. Check here for an analysis of the bill

What is Amendment 3 in Florida?

Amendment 3 is the amendment getting the most discussion in Florida.

The bill has two main impacts. First, it would increase the property tax exemption for homesteaded properties from the current $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and then $250,000 in 2028; afterwards, the exemption would increase with inflation.

Those exemptions would not apply to taxes for schools.

The amendment only applies to a person’s homesteaded property; it does not apply to commercial property or, crucially, to rental properties. The bill would cap the annual increase in assessed property value from going up by more than 5% annually; currently, increases in value are capped at 10%.

The bill would save taxpayers an estimated $12 billion annually at full implementation. But that savings will also leave a $12 billion hole in local government budgets, which depend on property taxes to fund services.

In Winter Park, officials have already begun trimming department budgets to prepare for the potential cuts.

City Manager Randy Knight has said most city functions will “survive” if Amendment 3 passes next month, but he’s warned of “pains” ahead in future years and the cuts continue to mount.

In the first year, the city would need to axe an estimated $3.7 million from its $90 million General Fund, which pays for everything from parks and roads to police and fire, followed by another $7.5 million the following year.

A Winter Park taxpayer who receives the maximum benefit would save about $850 in the first year and $1,780 in the second year, which equals nearly $150 a month, Knight said.

How the text will appear on your ballot:

This amendment increases the homestead exemption, for all non-school taxes, to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, and adjusts for inflation thereafter. It requires the Legislature to prescribe a uniform procedure for counties and municipalities, for their respective levies, to increase the homestead exemption up to full assessed value, and allows special districts, subject to referendum approval, to do the same. Persons who are not Florida residents on December 31, 2026, will receive the existing homestead exemption upon qualifying for a homestead exemption, with the increased homestead exemption beginning with the fifth year of exemption, to the extent permitted by the U.S. Constitution. This amendment reduces the annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead properties from 10% to 5%. This amendment requires counties and municipalities to use property taxes solely for public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, natural resources, bond debt service, retirement benefits for employees, and operations and administration. Other expenditures may be approved by county officers or county or municipal governing bodies unless prohibited by general law, notwithstanding Article VII, Section 9(a) of the Florida Constitution, which allows counties and municipalities to levy property taxes for their respective purposes. This amendment takes effect January 1, 2027.

Check here for the full text of the amendment. Check here for an analysis of the bill

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Jerry Demings Wins Approval for TDT Spending Plan

Jerry Demings Wins Approval for TDT Spending Plan

Jerry Demings Wins Approval for TDT Spending Plan

The amount for the Dr. Phillips arts center was reduced and commissioners rejected a bid to give the convention center more money

Oct. 19, 2026

By Beth Kassab

The Orange County Commission on Monday approved nearly $1 billion in projects funded by tourist development tax revenue, including new sports facilities at UCF and a $50 million reduction in funding for the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts.

A last-minute push to include several hundred million dollars for another expansion of the Orange County Convention Center, which has already cost $2 billion, failed to gain support from any commissioner except Mike Crabb, who was appointed to Seat 2 in August by Gov. Ron DeSantis.

Representatives of the tourism industry joined forces with local labor union members in an unusual alliance to urge Mayor Jerry Demings to delay a vote on his plan to spend $860 million on 13 projects. Demings refused, arguing that a delay could mean many projects he considered worthy might never get another chance at funding. He also bristled at assertions that the decision-making process lacked transparency or had been rushed, rejecting the suggestion that he should leave the matter to whoever is elected mayor next month.

“Yes, [the end of] our tenure is for some of us just months away, but it doesn’t mean that we should just sit here and do nothing,” Demings said. “This is my home, where I was born and raised. For nearly seven decades, I’ve lived here. I have put my life on the line for this community. Been in some tough situations over the years. My blood, my sweat, my tears have gone into working on behalf of this community. I will not retreat from working in my home and taking care of the people who live here.”

The 6-1 vote followed five hours of public testimony and debate.

Commissioner Kelly Semrad, who represents Winter Park, voted against the plan. Demings, Nicole Wilson, Crabb, Mayra Uribe, Maribel Gomez Cordero and Mike Scott voted in favor. Demings and Uribe are set to leave office soon, while Crabb and Scott are seeking election on Nov. 3.

Kelly Semrad

Nine speakers, many of whom worked in hotel management or other senior hospitality positions, urged the commission to add the convention center expansion to Demings’ list of projects.

Demings, however, said he was unwilling to consider such a change. The previous expansion, for which he helped secure funding, is still under construction, and he questioned whether another expansion was necessary for the center to remain nationally competitive.

“How big is big enough?” Demings asked. “How big is too big? And there are citizens who think that that’s not the appropriate place to make investments.”

Crabb twice attempted to amend Demings’ plan. He presented a spreadsheet he had prepared with different funding amounts for the projects to make room for the convention center expansion. After his first motion failed, he tried again, this time seeking to delay votes on both the convention center and the arts center while funding the other projects. Both times the other commissioners sat in silence rather than offering a second for his motions and both failed.

At least 14 of the 78 speakers told commissioners they were concerned about transportation in Orange County and wanted some tourist tax revenue directed toward improving roads, bus service and rail.

“I point out all these venues that you want to additionally fund are functional. They have options,” said Eugene Staccardo, a resident and civic activist. “This community doesn’t have an adequate transit system for tourism, even after billions of dollars of upgrades to I-4. It’s functionally not meeting the needs of [the] community … Say no to these large TDT proposals that will financially tie our hands for decades. Reserve the money for the future and to be used on hopefully a future transit system.”

Demings said he did not believe the Florida Legislature would expand the legally permitted uses of tourist development tax revenue to allow Orange County to spend the money on local needs such as public transportation.

“This legislature and those in the immediate past have not been so kind to this community,” he said. “They preempted us left and right. We have been left to figure it out on our own … Every one of these projects that we talked about today will add jobs. You would think that not any of those jobs are good jobs, but I’m here to tell you, many of those jobs are good jobs.”

Florida lawmakers have, however, granted exceptions allowing specific communities to use tourist tax revenue for local needs, such as affordable housing and public safety, after those communities mounted strong campaigns for the changes.

Semrad questioned why her colleagues were willing to disregard both residents’ concerns about transportation and projections in Demings’ own plan showing that TDT reserves would fall below the recommended $300 million threshold in the coming years as a result of the spending.

 

Demings and county staff members said the projections assumed annual TDT revenue growth of 2% over much of the next 10 years, though actual growth could be higher. They also said the county’s convention center capital spending plan includes additional TDT revenue for projects such as elevator repairs and fire alarm system replacements. Because those funds are not always fully spent, they argued, the projections were conservative.

“You’re okay with it, and I hear all the reasons why that math works,” Semrad told the group. “But I’m also familiar with market uncertainty and the conditions in today’s marketplace that are concerning, and that numbers could soften, especially in terms of travel. We all see it at the pumps. You guys, anybody who’s bought an airline ticket lately knows how expensive it’s getting. It’s going to impact our tourism industry … So I’m uncomfortable when I see red numbers.”

Ultimately, Uribe moved to keep reserves at the recommended threshold by reducing the allocation for the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts from $400 million to $350 million.

The arts center is receiving the largest share of the mayor’s TDT spending plan to build new theaters, add parking and make other improvements.

Kathy Ramsberger, the center’s president and CEO, addressed the commission and confirmed that the center could still move forward with its projects under the reduced allocation.

The following slides show the approved spending plan with the exception of the reduced arts center figure:

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmaill.com

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

What’s Going On? I-Drive Chamber, Unions, Kelly Semrad All Call to Slow Down Giving Away TDT Money

What’s Going On? I-Drive Chamber, Unions, Kelly Semrad All Call to Slow Down Giving Away TDT Money

What's Going On? I-Drive Chamber, Unions, Kelly Semrad All Call to Slow Down Giving Away TDT Money

The unusual allies expressed concerns ahead of a meeting today where the County Commission is set to consider Mayor Jerry Demings’ plan to give out nearly $1 billion

Oct. 19, 2026

By Beth Kassab

When the Chamber of Commerce that represents the largest tourism interests on International Drive aligns with both the local labor union and the county commissioner who was elected on a campaign of pushing back against tourism’s political power, it’s a rare day in Orange County.

Those unusual allies appear to have different motivations, but they’re calling for the same thing: They want Orange Mayor Jerry Demings to slow down his push to allocate nearly $1 billion in Tourist Development Tax revenue to 13 projects without subjecting each one to greater scrutiny or more fully assessing what local communities will need over the long term.

Today, those groups will be seeking answers to a number of questions when Demings and County Commissioners meet this afternoon for a special meeting at which Demings will seek approval of his recommendations for the 13 projects.

Among those questions, which center on a process that began in late July with the first meeting of Demings’ 34-member citizen task force to evaluate the projects, are:

  • How and why was a proposal to spend $46 million on new soccer and track-and-field facilities at the University of Central Florida (UCF) added back to Demings’ list as his 13th recommendation after the citizen task force made only 12 recommendations and funding for UCF didn’t even garner enough support for a full vote?
  • Will proponents of another expansion of the Orange County Convention Center succeed in getting that project added to the recommendation list in the final hours, even though the citizen task force also rejected it?
  • Were all the projects evaluated using the same comparable metrics and standards agreed upon by the task force to justify the use of public dollars?
  • If the County Commission funds all 13 projects at the recommended levels, will any additional hotel bed-tax revenue be available for transportation or other local needs if the state eventually allows the expanded uses of the tax revenue recommended by the citizen task force? Both candidates seeking to become Florida’s next governor have expressed support for expanding those uses.

“Government moves slow until you put a billion dollars on the table for the tourism industry then it moves at the speed of light,” said Commissioner Kelly Semrad, who represents Winter Park, describing the timeline, which began less than three months ago.

Today’s meeting could provide the last major opportunity for debate on Demings’ plan to spend more than $860 million, mostly over the next 10 years. Some of the financial obligations, however, would extend much longer. Debt service on a major expansion of the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts, for example, would cost about $32.8 million annually for as long as 30 years.

The plan outlined by Mayor Jerry Demings as presented recently to county commissioners.

The meeting comes just two weeks before Election Day, when voters will select a new mayor and four commissioners, and about eight weeks before the winners are sworn into office.

John Stine, chairman of the International Drive Resort Area Chamber of Commerce, called the process “rushed and flawed” in a letter to the editor published in Sunday’s Orlando Sentinel.

“County commissioners have a responsibility to independently examine the recommendations before committing funds,” Stine wrote. “A task force recommendation should begin that scrutiny, not replace it. Unanswered questions require answers. Incomplete financial information requires further review.”

Similarly, the union representing food-service, housekeeping, and other workers at Walt Disney World and hotels near Universal Orlando and the Convention Center called for more time before the financial commitments are finalized.

Union leaders said Sunday in a news release that they would hold a news conference just before Demings’ meeting to urge the county to “take more time to evaluate the size and scope of the proposed commitments, provide greater transparency on the TDT financial picture, preserve flexibility for future transportation investments, and ensure tourism workers and the incoming County Commission have an opportunity to weigh in before long-term decisions are finalized.”

According to the county webpage dedicated to the citizen task force, today’s work session will be followed by a special Tourist Development Tax meeting on Nov. 6 and then a regular County Commission meeting on Dec. 1, just days before Demings is scheduled to leave office.

Linda Chapin, the former Orange County mayor who served as co-chair of the citizen task force, defended its process in an interview with the Voice on Sunday.

“We spent twice as much time on this task force as the last one did,” Chapin said. “We heard from three times as many applicants as the last one did, and we worked very hard to make sure this money benefited people across the community, so I will be very disappointed if they don’t move ahead.”

She said she was pleased that projects from Ocoee to Eatonville to more money to be handed out later to smaller arts organizations made it into the recommendations. She pointed to recent projects in Winter Park that received tourist development tax dollars such as the Rollins art museum and the Winter Park Playhouse as examples of how the tax is benefiting communities across the county rather than just in the central tourism areas.

Chapin did acknowledge, however, that she was “a little surprised” to see UCF’s project added to Demings’ recommendations after no one on the task force seconded a motion to include it among the projects the group endorsed.

She also said she was “very frustrated” that the task force was never given specifics about how much money it had to work with as it met in July and August.

A PowerPoint presentation provided to commissioners by county staff last week included a chart showing that the projected costs of the 13 projects would exceed revenues from 2028 through 2032 before the balance returned to positive territory in 2033. The tax’s unallocated cash reserves, or rainy-day fund, would dip below the comptroller’s recommended target of $300 million in 2031, 2032, and 2033, according to projections that assume 8% growth in TDT revenue in 2026 and 2% annual growth thereafter.

But Chapin dismissed the notion that funding the recommended projects would tie up all available funds for the next decade. She also said she was concerned about what might really be driving some calls to slow the process until a new County Commission takes office.

“I fear that for some of these people, not all, it’s a ploy to see if they can put it off until the next board so they can give money to the convention center,” Chapin said.

She plans to attend today’s work session and said, “if I need to issue a red flag about the convention center, I’ll stand up and do it.”

Semrad and others, including Winter Park Mayor Sheila DeCiccio, who advocate directing more of the tax revenue toward local needs such as transportation infrastructure, say the latest convention center expansion’s failure to win approval from the task force was a victory for the community. They view the convention center, which has already cost $2 billion, as primarily benefiting hotels and businesses along International Drive.

Mike Crabb, who was appointed by Gov. Ron DeSantis to represent District 2, which includes Apopka, and is now in a runoff on Nov. 3 against Kamia Brown, sent a memo to fellow commissioners last week urging them to add the convention center back to the list of projects slated for funding. Among other recommendations, he suggested allocating $523 million to the convention center while reducing the $400 million Demings recommended for the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts to $150 million.

Commissioner Mike Scott, who represents the International Drive area, along with Tangelo Park and Pine Hills, and is seeking reelection next month against Lawanna Gelzer, also pushed to reconsider the convention center at a recent commission meeting.

Roseann Harrington, Demings’ chief of staff, said in an email to Semrad that the mayor had the discretion to add UCF back to the list because “commissioners mentioned three times” when they accepted the task force’s recommendations in August that the action “did not limit them to only selecting among the 12 recommended by the TDT Task Force. Commissioners expressed interest in the Orange County Convention Center (OCCC) and UCF.”

When Semrad, a UCF professor who studies hospitality economics, asked for more detail about how the projects were evaluated for economic impact and why the county used a traditional economic analysis rather than what she considered more informative measures — such as jobs and wages, geographic reach, long-term operating costs, financial sustainability, and future TDT revenue generation — Harrington suggested that Semrad conduct her own analysis.

“After speaking with six of the seven BCC members on the type of fiscal analysis they would like conducted, the consensus was to do a traditional economic analysis consistent with the work done by GSU,” Harrington wrote. “With that said, since you have expertise in financial and community analysis, please feel free to do your own research and we will be glad to distribute to the BCC.”

Semrad argued that clearer guidelines were needed not only for the metrics but also for the process.

“My concern is that both the applicant pool and the scope of that analysis appear to have changed without further public Board discussion,” she wrote to Harrington.

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com 

 

To comment or read comments from others, click here →

Commission Delays Merrywood Vote as Preservation Talks Continue

Commission Delays Merrywood Vote as Preservation Talks Continue

Commission Delays Merrywood Vote as Preservation Talks Continue

Matt Morgan is still trying to buy the property as Commissioner Kris Cruzada pushes for compromise for ‘conscience’ of city

Oct. 15, 2026

By Beth Kassab

The fate of Merrywood remained uncertain the morning after a more than four-hour meeting devoted to determining how much, if any, of the historic property must be preserved for its new owner to get permission from the City Commission to split the lakefront lot he purchased in August for $15 million into two.

As these debates often do in Winter Park, the discussion touched on more than the fate of one house. For many, it reflected a collective angst over losing the architectural diversity and history that, along with its walkability and lush tree canopy, have long earned the city acclaim as a destination for visitors and people seeking a Florida lifestyle in a New England-style village.

Natalie Brethauer, one of at least 10 people who signed up to speak at the meeting, illustrated that tension between old and new. She told commissioners she grew up in Winter Park, moved away for college and lived in other vibrant cities, including Denver, Houston and the Old Town neighborhood of Alexandria, Va., before returning home and marrying at the Capen House, which had been slated for demolition before it was floated across Lake Osceola to be preserved.

“The whole reason I came back to Winter Park is because it is such a unique and beautiful place to raise a family and live,” she told commissioners. “And something that I’ve noticed since moving back, and it’s really ramped up post-COVID … It looks as though it’s like a dystopian-type vibe happening here. You go down Palmer [Avenue], and to me, I describe it as like an evil villain lair in ‘The Incredibles’ movie or something. Like, what are these homes that are being built? I thought the whole point of Winter Park was its beautiful historical charm, and that was the lure and the draw, and so it’s just really sad to see a lot of that going away.”

She was referring to the proliferation of what have become known as “white box” houses. Though they aren’t always white, the homes feature sharp edges and an ultra-modern aesthetic more common in, say, Miami Beach than along the local brick streets fronting the Chain of Lakes.

After the meeting, Commissioner Kris Cruzada, who voted in June along with Mayor Sheila DeCiccio and Craig Russell to approve a lot split without any preservation conditions, said he considered Brethauer’s comments representative of part of the “conscience” of Winter Park. He said that sentiment was one reason he pushed so hard Wednesday night for a compromise that would preserve some portion of Merrywood in exchange for allowing the lot split.

Attorney Jason Searl, who represents Steve Lockwood, points to areas on the Merrywood facade that could potentially be saved.

The property at 1020 Palmer Ave. has already set a record for the highest sale price in Winter Park at $15 million. It would become even more valuable if it were subdivided so that a portion could be sold separately.

Lockwood said during the meeting that a close family friend wanted to purchase the new lot and build a house there. Lockwood, who sat through the hours-long meeting with his wife and daughter, said he plans to build a new house for his family behind Merrywood. The existing house would be at least partially demolished and converted into what he called a “guest house.”

After the meeting, Lockwood told the Voice he would hire an architect and try to determine what would be feasible under a condition proposed by Cruzada that would require preserving a portion of the nearly 90-year-old estate. The house was designed by James Gamble Rogers II and is listed in Florida’s database of historic and cultural assets.

Cruzada’s shift in position was key to the commission’s unanimous 5-0 vote to delay a decision until Nov. 11, giving new owner Steve Lockwood time to outline what portion of the house he believes could be preserved.

Commissioners discussed retaining only a portion of the facade, or front wall, while gutting everything else.

New Merrywood owner Steve Lockwood speaks at the City Commission meeting on Wednesday.

“Just like a billboard?” asked Commissioner Craig Russell, conjuring the image of an old Hollywood set piece.

Even after the meeting was recessed to give the owner and his lawyer time to try to work out some terms, it remained unclear how much of the house would need to be preserved to secure at least three votes on the commission, or how much Lockwood considered feasible and affordable.

Throughout the meeting, Lockwood and his attorney, Jason Searl of Maynard Nexsen, pointed to inspection and engineering reports that appeared to have been prepared earlier this year, when Tara Tedrow was still under contract to buy the property. The reports indicated that the house was in a state of disrepair beyond saving.

Searl showed commissioners an overhead projection of the house and pointed to a section of the facade, perhaps 30 feet long, that he said could potentially be restored.

That led to an exchange among commissioners that got to the heart of the discussion.

Commissioner Elizabeth Ingram said 30 feet was inadequate.

“That’s not the architecture,” she said. ” That’s not the beauty of the home. It’s not the house anymore. To me, if you were willing to keep that entire facade, that front whole section where you have the extra height on this side, and then you have the little rounded space around the side. That is the coolness. That is the charm and the beauty and the style of James Gamble Rogers.”

Ingram also said preserving so little would “erode” the city’s comprehensive plan, which must be amended to allow the lakefront lot to be split. The plan generally prohibits lakefront lot splits.

“That doesn’t encourage one bit of historic preservation, which we all claim to love and respect and want to promote, but then we’re going to be OK with just keeping 30 feet of this ginormous, beautiful home? Like, what are we doing?”

Cruzada argued that preserving some of the house was better than preserving none of it.

“I guess what I’m trying to do is find a path to some level of preservation or we lose it all together,” Cruzada said. “You know, we’re in an unfortunate set of circumstances. He’s here before us trying to compromise.”

“No, he’s here trying to have us compromise our comp plan,” Ingram replied.

“You’re right,” Cruzada said. “But the other side is if we don’t allow the lot split, then he’s still going to go forward with the demolition permit. Then we don’t have anything.”

Lockwood, who owns federal government medical staffing contractor Loyal Source and last year purchased the Orlando-based drinkware brand Corkcicle, and his attorney opened the meeting by saying they were unwilling to put any preservation conditions in writing beyond a commitment that Lockwood would make a “good faith” effort to preserve a portion of the house.

Searl proposed allowing any square footage Lockwood preserved to count toward the potential additional square footage of the new homes on the divided lot. The commission has sought to limit the combined size of the homes to 30,000 square feet.

Searl said that if commissioners did not approve the lot split Wednesday, Lockwood would move forward with demolishing the house and potentially seek approval for the lot split in the future. He quoted former owner Cathy Gilmer, who spoke during the June meeting and called the house “basically a waste” that falls further into disrepair every day it remains standing.

Searl said Lockwood was discouraged and offended by an open letter to the City Commission, organized by the Friends of Casa Feliz and signed by nearly 300 people, that called on the city to deny the lot split unless Lockwood agreed to designate the house as historic.

The letter came as a disappointment and a surprise, Searl said, after Lockwood spent two hours meeting with the leaders of Casa Feliz, another Gamble Rogers-designed house that was saved 25 years ago when it was moved across Interlachen Avenue to its current location on the Winter Park Nine. It now serves as a museum and popular event venue.

“When that happened, it feels like to us you’re then fighting a losing battle, and anything you say will not achieve a cooperative spirit from that group,” Searl said.

When it was Betsy Owens’ turn to speak, she explained that Lockwood knew about the letter and called for at least 80% of the house to be preserved, including the entire front elevation.

“When Mr. Lockwood and I met last week, I mentioned this letter,” said Owens, executive director of Friends of Casa Feliz. “It’s been in circulation for about two months, so this was not at all a reaction to that meeting. We were very upfront about that. We recognize an uncomfortable reality: Merrywood is not historically designated and could be legally demolished tomorrow, but today the city has something it ordinarily lacks, and that is leverage. The owner is asking you to change the comprehensive plan. That gives you an opportunity to secure preservation protections in return … We understand that saving some portion is better than losing all of it. We don’t want the perfect to be the enemy of the good.”

Lockwood later apologized for misunderstanding the open letter, saying he thought it was a new letter rather than the one Owens had already told him about.

After initially insisting he would not agree to delay the vote and would rather face a rejection than push the hearing to another meeting, Lockwood ultimately agreed to wait until November.

Matt Morgan, center, listens to the debate over Merrywood during the Winter Park City Commission meeting.

That leaves four weeks for a potential compromise to take shape or another twist to emerge in the saga of Merrywood.

Matt Morgan, one of the faces of the Morgan & Morgan law firm who lives in a historic home in Winter Park not far from Merrywood, sat in the commission chambers for nearly the entire meeting but did not speak.

On Thursday morning, he sent a letter to commissioners reiterating his desire to purchase the property. Morgan emerged publicly as a potential buyer over the summer after commissioners were told during the first vote that Merrywood had to be demolished because no one was willing to invest the money needed to restore it.

“I want to make certain the commission understands that I am willing to assume the financial responsibility and substantial undertaking necessary to preserve and restore the home,” Morgan wrote on Thursday morning. “I recently offered to purchase Merrywood for its pro rata share of the $12 million contract price. I also indicated that, upon reviewing the operating agreement for Lake Osceola Holdings, I would be willing to increase that offer.”

Tedrow reportedly had the property under contract for $12 million contingent on the lot split going through. Lockwood purchased the property under Lake Osceola Holdings LLC for $15 million, though his identity wasn’t known until last week and it’s unclear why the price went up by $3 million.

Morgan said Searl has told him the property is not for sale.

But Morgan said he remained hopeful the house would be preserved and expressed relief that the second and final vote on the lot split was delayed.

“Thank God they took a breath,” he said. “Because they were getting ready to entirely change the code on a hope and a prayer.”

WinterParkVoiceEditor@gmail.com

 

 

 

 

To comment or read comments from others, click here →